Custom orders and special offerings!

We take your special day to the next level: send us an inquiry for complete dessert bars for weddings, showers, etc.

About Bakeshop Local

Mill Stream Farm offers custom ordering for local patrons, whether you are in need of custom cakes, cupcakes or sheetcakes, we would be happy to bake to your specifications.  Please find information below on the types of cupcakes and cakes we offer. (We always welcome your own preferences when we can accommodate!)

To make an inquiry, complete the form below, adding relevant details as needed, and we will reach out to you as soon as possible with an estimate for your custom order.  Final price will be determined by the amount of detail and supply needed to complete the cake.

We require a minimum of one weeks’ notice for cupcake orders, and two weeks’ notice for cakes. A last-minute rush order will depend upon availability and will add an additional $50 charge.

Get Started Now!

Frequently Asked Questions

For wedding orders, we can book out months in advance.  All orders require a 50% non-refundable deposit at the time of the order to hold the date, with the balance due two (2) weeks prior to delivery. Without this deposit, your date cannot be held and may become unavailable. Most clients book us as soon as they become engaged – this way their wedding date is secured.  The first step is to fill out our Details form.

For cupcakes and all-occasion cakes, orders must be placed two (2) weeks in advance and must be paid in full at time of order.

Fill out and submit the “Details” form.  We will contact you with a quote or to set up a consultation.  Be certain to include as much detail as possible!
All orders require a 50% non-refundable deposit at the time of the order to hold the date, with the balance due two (2) weeks prior to delivery. Without this deposit, your date cannot be held and may become unavailable.  Once we have established all details and the quote is acceptable, you can pay online or by mail.  We accept all major credit cards and local checks, as well as the green stuff.  There is a 3% processing fee on all credit/debit card orders.
Yes we do!  We schedule tastings at your home, if local, which is helpful when discussing details.  Although we don’t have a shop, we do have a commercial kitchen space which is inviting as well.   You are also able to pick up a tasting box to go, if scheduling an in-person appointment is inconvenient . . .  There is a non-refundable $45 fee for tasting appointments/boxes. The tasting usually consists of three cake flavors of your choice with your choice of fillings/icing.  Other dessert bar items are not offered for tasting.

Pricing Overview

The below chart indicates pricing for ALL-OCCASION AND CELEBRATION CAKES AND CUPCAKES.  {Weddings begin at $7/serving cake & $8-$10/serving dessert bar; each wedding requires customized pricing and our wedding minimum is $500.00 . . . Begin by filling out inquiry form below}

Item Options Starting at
Cupcakes Regular
Dairy, Gluten Free or Filled
Theme Wrappers and/or Toppers
$2.50 ea | $30/doz
$3.00 ea | $36/doz
$5.00/doz additional charge
2-Layer All Occasion Cakes (3 layer talls now special request – add additional $20.00)
(all occasion cakes are one tier; multiple tiers fall under wedding pricing)
 6″ Round (serves approx. 12)
8″ Round (serves approx. 20)
10″ Round (serves approx. 36)
Sheet Cakes
(one layer, unless otherwise specified for an additional fee)
1/4 Sheet (8″ x 12″) serves 18-24
1/2 Sheet (12″ x 16″) serves 36-54
Full Sheet (16″ x 24″) serves 64-96Dairy or Gluten-Free -*Additional*
$185.00*Add $15.00
Texas Sheetcake 11″ x 15″ x 2″ single layer $45.00 ea

Popular Flavors

Classic Cakes

Flavor Options:

Vanilla Bean
Yellow Butter
Red Velvet or White Velvet


Signature Cakes

Flavor Options:

Cinnamon Swirl
Apple Cake
Fresh Strawberry
Pink Champagne

Icing Options

American Buttercreams:

Cream Cheese
Pink Champagne

Orange Citrus
Vanilla Almond

Filling Options

Red Raspberry
Lemon Curd
Chocolate Ganache
Boston Creme

Fig Compote

Details, please!

Custom Order
* Required for wedding inquiries
* Required for wedding inquiries
Please make sure you add to your safe domain list to ensure that our response does not get lost in your spam folder. (Our replies may come from, and/or
Time *
Please list any food allergies of which we may need to be aware as general information. MSF will not be held liable for any allergic reactions. Enter "None" if no food allergies need to be taken into consideration.
Please provide any additional details that might be helpful. If you would like other desserts included in a dessert bar, other cake/cupcake flavors that are not on our list, please specify. Please be as descriptive as possible.